There
are three strata in Hinduism:
a)
High Metaphysics that is radically monistic.
However, in practice, monism behaves like pantheism, a subtle shade
of which pervades the whole of Hinduism. We may call this stratum ‘metaphysical
pantheism’.
b)
Popular religion based on mythology
that, in practice, is polytheistic. However,
in principle, all the gods are admitted to be manifestations of the one God. Popular religion also has to deal
with demons; these are
not the objects of love and devotion but of fear. So the demons have to be kept
out of mischief with gifts. We may call this stratum ‘mythological
polytheism’.
c)
The above two strata are extremes. Between the two lies the Hindu religion
proper, of which the doctrine can be categorised under the three headings of God, the world, and the Soul. It is precisely in the notion of God that we come
upon the moral problem of idolatry.
There is first the metaphysical notion of the impersonal
Absolute. Considered in himself, God is impersonal. Then there is the religious notion of the personal God.
In relation to the world, God is personal. The mythological notion contains the explanation of the mode of relationship of God to the
world. God assumes three distinct forms corresponding to the respective
functions of Creator, Conserver and Consummation. This is Trimurti, the divine
Triad or group of three. However, this is essentially different from the
Christian doctrine of the Trinity. Trimurti is only the outward expression of
God, not his inward nature. The Christian Trinity is three persons in one
substance; whereas Trimurti is one essence in three substances.
Avatara is one of the central doctrines of Hinduism. The
descent of God commonly called “incarnation”. But the real characteristic of
Avatara is a theophany or divine manifestation that is essentially different from the Incarnation of the Word. Thus Vishnu
descends in visible form to save the world from disaster. The most important
avataras were Rama and Krishna, which gave a strong impetus to the religion of
love.
Arcavatara is a complement to the doctrine of Avatara, namely,
the indwelling of the divinity in the consecrated idol. There is no idea here
of transubstantiation but of a type of incarnation, the divinity assuming the
idol as its body. All the same, the sentiments of a devout Hindu may be very
like that of a Catholic about the Eucharist.
Having a deep sense of the sacred,
the Hindu can single out any person or object as the focus of the divinity.
Ignorant of the personal and inner life of God as revealed in Jesus Christ, his
efforts reach sense reality by means of a thousand signs and symbols and idols
– a yearning search for God. But ignorance, weakness and sin have vitiated this
search. Jesus Christ prevents us from idolatry. Thus idolatry is a search for
God and at the same time a turning away from him, a prayer and refusal,
adoration and a sacrilege. Symbols are unworthy since they are man-made. The
multiplicity breaks up the divine oneness. Clinging to the idol prevents
reaching out to the Transcendent One. On the other hand, the images are at
least occasions of genuine and humble prayer in the daily life of many.
Idolatry does not imply the belief
that God is a mere statue or finite being, but the quite different assumption
that a statue can be made to become God or God’s abode or body, that a finite
person or symbol can be an adequate object of adoration. In the holy Eucharist
the bread is not the abode of Christ. There is no bread; there is only Jesus Christ, whole and entire,
whom we adore as our Transcendent Lord in the order of very existence.
The idol-image, symbol or finite
person, embodies man’s desires and conceptions rather than God’s transcendent
claims and divine fullness. Clinging to the idols of his family, culture and
nation, the idolater can refuse to surrender in spirit and truth to God’s
self-revelation.
Image worship is sinful when it
degenerates into magic or into attempts to placate finite beings like ghosts,
demons, natural forces, and so on. In polytheism, at least on the practical
plane, the divine oneness is fragmented into aspects and forms, each form being
personified and worshipped as person. Worship can be expressed by invocation,
reverence and adoration. The worshipper-worshipped relation is a personal one,
and if it implies adoration then the relation is one of complete surrender such
as only the absolute transcendent can claim. To establish this relation with
any thing or person short of the Absolute is sinful. This is what idolatry
does: human individuals are deified or aspects of the divinity are humanised in
concrete forms for the devotees to worship.
Worship is not mere meditation. We
need symbols to think of the Absolute. But we do not worship
the symbols in order to think of the Absolute. We rather
contemplate the symbol to worship the Absolute. (Nobody adores the Shroud of
Turin; the shroud is only an occasion of the prayer of adoration of and
thanksgiving to Jesus). So we do not worship our symbols or thoughts. Symbols
are finite and human. They are man made and are the expressions of our own
desires and therefore hold out no challenge to us. Whereas, the Eucharist is instituted
by Christ, a God-given symbol, and continues to call us to enter
into the Paschal Mystery of Jesus Christ. The idols of the image-makers are at
best a sort of “personifications” of the divine.
Idolatry can be a groping movement
towards God. But it can also become a clinging to the self, since idols are
things that man makes. For a Christian it would definitely be a running away
from the light.
We adore no image of the divinity,
except the subsistent and living image of the Father, the Person of Jesus
Christ, since “he is the image of the invisible God” (Col 1, 15), and “in him
everything continues in being (vs. 17b). The statues and pictures of Christ,
his Cross, Sacred Heart, and Divine Mercy are objects of worship for us by relationship to the Divine Person. They
are not “personified” or enlivened embodiments of the Divine. The Eucharist we adore directly. The very Person of God the Son is there, not any
image or symbol.